The Reintegration Report Card

We are pleased to publish “The Reintegration Report Card,” a new resource that ranks and grades all 50 states on how their laws address voting rights, record relief (including expungement and pardon), fair employment, and occupational licensing for people with a criminal record.

This Report Card supplements our recent 50-state report, “The Many Roads to Reintegration.” That report surveys U.S. laws aimed at restoring rights and opportunities after arrest or conviction. It grades the states on nine different types of restoration laws, including voting rights, six different record relief remedies, and laws regulating consideration of criminal record in employment and occupational licensing. Based on these grades, the report includes an overall ranking of the states and D.C.

This Report Card provides the grades and rankings in a more easily accessible form. It also includes a brief narrative summary of how each state’s law stacks up in the different graded categories. Our hope is that these summaries will suggest ways in which a state might improve its laws and hence its overall ranking. An appendix collects all the grades and rankings (the rankings are also at the end of this post).

We emphasize once again that our grades are based solely on the text of each state’s law, leaving more nuanced judgments about their actual operation to practitioners, researchers, and the law’s intended beneficiaries. We expect to look more closely at the operation of some of the record relief laws in the near future, and welcome comments and suggestions from those who have experience with them. In the meantime, we hope our grades will challenge, encourage, and inspire additional reforms in the months and years ahead.

The Reintegration Report Card is available at this link. For more details and legal citations for each state, see the Restoration of Rights Project. For essays surveying each topic, consult “The Many Roads to Reintegration.”

National Ranking of States on Laws Restoring Rights and Opportunities

1

2

3

4

5

5

7

8

8

10

10

12

12

12

15

15

17

Illinois

California

Utah

Minnesota

Connecticut

Nevada

Colorado

Delaware

New York

N. Dakota

Pennsylvania

N. Hampshire

New Jersey

Oklahoma

Massachusetts

New Mexico

Indiana

18

18

18

18

18

23

23

23

26

27

27

27

30

30

32

33

34

Louisiana

Nebraska

Rhode Island

Vermont

Washington

Arkansas

Kentucky

Ohio

North Carolina

Idaho

Michigan

Tennessee

Missouri

Wisconsin

Georgia

Mississippi

Hawaii

35

36

36

36

39

40

41

42

42

44

44

46

46

48

49

50

51

Maryland

Arizona

Oregon

S. Carolina

Maine

D.C.

Kansas

Montana

West Virginia

South Dakota

Virginia

Iowa

Wyoming

Texas

Alabama

Alaska

Florida